TO: District Policy Committee Members
FROM: Jeffrey W. Aluotto, Solid Waste Manager
Cory R. Chadwick, Director
I. Introduction/Opening Comments
NOTICE: This memo is for the meeting to be held on January 10 , 2002. This meeting will be held at 2:00 p.m. in the conference room of NU-BLEND Paints, located at 40 E. McMicken, Cincinnati, Ohio 45210.
Policy Committee Information (Agendas, Manager's Memos, Minutes, etc.) now available on the District's Website at www.hcdoes.org.
II. Clerk's Report/Additions to the Agenda
A. Approval of Minutes - November 8, 2001
Minutes from the November 8, 2001 Policy Committee Meeting are included as Attachment
A for the Policy Committee's review and approval.
B. Additions to the Agenda
Please contact Susan Schumacher at 946-7734 if you have items to add to the agenda.
A. Finance Subcommittee Briefings for November 8, 2001 and January 10, 2002
Mr. Graham will provide a brief report regarding the items discussed and reviewed at the
Finance Subcommittee meetings of November 8, 2001 and January 10, 2002.
B. Recommendation Regarding District Disbursements - SWR 01/2002
The Finance Subcommittee reviewed the expenditures at their meeting held prior to this
meeting.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: With any alterations or corrections noted by the Finance Subcommittee members or Policy Committee members, the Staff recommends approval of SWR 01/2002.
IV. Policy Items
A. Presentation - Cinergy: Application to ODNR for Scrap Tire Market Development
Grant
Representatives from Cinergy will be present to detail the company's plan to apply for Scrap
Tire Market Development Grant funds through the Ohio Department of Natural Resources.
Cinergy plans on exploring the use of scrap tire material as a low-cost fuel source. In
appropriate situations, TDF (tire derived fuel) has been shown to be a cost-effective, less
polluting fuel option, for coal-fired utility boilers. This project has the potential to
significantly affect the market for scrap tires, and the uses for scrap tires, in southwestern
Ohio. As this grant program is structured as an ODNR Market Development Grant,
applications from private entities must go through a solid waste management district.
Our region does have some past experience with TDF projects. Several years ago, Champion Paper tested the use of TDF as supplemental boiler fuel. Stack testing analysis from that test showed that all emissions, with the exception of CO and Chlorine, were reduced with the addition of supplemental TDF fuel. Please see Attachment B for a brief analysis of TDF as a fuel source.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the Policy Committee approve the submission of a Scrap Tire Market Development Grant, by the District, on behalf of the Cinergy Corporation.
Applications for the General Interest Representative and Generator Representative were submitted and forwarded to the four permanent members of the Policy Committee.
Under State law, the four permanent members are responsible for nominating and appointing individuals to fill these two positions. This process will be undertaken at this meeting.
As such, this will be the final official meeting for Wright Gwyn, General Interest Representative and Phil Geis, Generator Representative. I would like to personally thank each of them for their hard work and dedication to the District over the past four years.
Staff has continued to work on this issue and has been in contact with State Representative Steve Driehaus and Rep. Bill Seitz, both of whom have pledged support for the City of Cincinnati's Housing Court initiative. In addition, both see great potential for linking that effort with a potential County Environmental Court. District Staff are in the process of attempting to set up a meeting with City of Cincinnati Staff to begin discussing the City's effort and the Policy Committee's proposal.
District Staff have submitted a request to the Regional Computer Center asking for details on the number of cases, heard in Municipal Court, related to Litter, Open Dumping, the State Building Code, Hamilton County Building Code, City of Cincinnati Building and Housing Code, Hamilton County's Zoning Resolution, Stormwater, Soil and Water Conservation District Regulations and several other miscellaneous code violations (Animal offenses, weeds, etc.). Results of this search are pending.
Staff contacted several of the Mayor's Courts existing in the County and discovered that while most of them serve as the forum for hearing litter/dumping related cases, these cases rarely appear there. An exception was Norwood which hears about 20 litter cases per year. Few other courts hear more than 1 litter/dumping case every two months. Those Mayor's Courts contacted stated that they predominantly hear traffic cases (Individual courts also noted certain other cases heard in significant numbers including housing violations and bad checks).
In terms of the financial benefits of Mayor's Courts to local political subdivisions, surveyed political subdivisions indicated revenues ranging from $24,000 - $240,000 per year.
There are several options for proceeding in this matter. Hamilton County has representatives willing to sponsor legislation, based upon recommendations from interested parties, and several agencies and departments interested in becoming party to such an initiative. In addition, the City of Cincinnati, while it seems their effort has stalled slightly, remains interested in pursuing a Housing Court. It remains uncertain as to whether there is an existing case-load to justify the creation of a new court for these types of nuisance violations. However, other solutions might be just as appropriate (i.e. One idea which has been discussed is to have Municipal Court work with the Ohio Supreme Court to change the Rules of Superintendence to allow these minor misdemeanor cases to roll to one specific Judge on a half or quarter time basis, or to a magistrate). Regardless of the final solution, however, it would be recommended that this item be recommended to the Board of Commissioners where, if desired, it can assume higher status than what the District can offer via additional research.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: District Staff recommends passing the Resolution offered by Public Member, Jim O'Reilly, with any changes and amendments to be submitted at the meeting of January 10th, to allow the District's recommendation on the Environmental Court to proceed to the Board of County Commissioners for consideration.
D. Fee Structure
At the last District Policy Committee meeting, there was a brief discussion regarding issues relating to the District's fee structure. Staff recommended, at that meeting, that the District proceed with allowing Eastman and Smith to put together a plan describing how an alternative fee structure, relying on the County's designation authority, would be implemented for Hamilton County and how questions of law (specifically those posed by District Policy Committee Members) would be addressed in any new fee structure.
The Policy Committee requested that Staff first receive a quote on this work. Eastman and Smith has informed Staff that this work could be done for a price not to exceed $2,500.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the District enter into an agreement, with Eastman and Smith, not to exceed $2,500, to develop a plan detailing how an alternative fee structure (similar to the Maharg fee structure) would specifically be structured and implemented in Hamilton County.
V. Informational Items
A. Facility Updates
On November 5, 2001, Rumpke submitted a Permit to Install Application to OEPA for a
vertical expansion of their landfill on the northwest portion of their facility. This expansion
will not change the existing footprint of the landfill and will encompass an area of
approximately 67 acres on the existing facility. A portion of this expansion will be over a
previously placed liner system while a portion will require the construction of a new liner.
Members of District Staff and Staff from the Hamilton County General Health District attended a public meeting on this planned expansion on December 10.
Waste Management, Inc. held an open house for their newly constructed transfer station on December 11. The facility has received its Certificate of Occupancy and is awaiting upon a license from the Cincinnati Health Department to begin operation.
B. Market Development Grant Pre-Proposal
The District recently submitted pre-proposals on behalf of the Omaha Paper Stock Company
(OPSC) and Community Access to Technology (CAT) for Market Development funds
through ODNR. OPSC would like to invest in some small-scale recycling processing
capacity to handle approximately 10 tons per day of co-mingled curbside material. OPSC
receives this material from other haulers in the area which provide curbside recycling but do
not have ready access to processing capacity. CAT is seeking funds for equipment and
supplies to expand their ability to process and recycle used computer and electronic
equipment.
HB 459 was recently introduced into the General Assembly by Rep. Kirk Schuring. This Bill calls for a commission to be established to analyze several facets of Ohio's current solid waste law. Solid Waste Districts and Counties will play an integral role in this analysis (three of the 31 commission members will be from solid waste management districts and three will be from counties). The Organization of Solid Waste Districts of Ohio will be meeting with representatives of CCAO to begin to map out a strategy for participating in this process. The Policy Committee will be kept informed on news and issues pertaining to this legislation. The Bill can be found using the following link :
http://www.legislature.state.oh.us/bills.cfm?ID=124_HB_459
The regional recycling workshop that the District is coordinating, with ODNR and the Association of Ohio Recyclers will occur on June 5. An additional workshop will take place in Stark County will be held on June 4 or June 6. Recently, the Organization of Solid Waste Districts of Ohio and the Ohio Chapter of the Solid Waste Association of North America agreed to serve as additional co-sponsors for the workshops.
The planning committee will be advertising these workshops through individual mailing lists as well as through the Ohio Municipal League and the Ohio Township Association.
Following the Policy Committee's approval of a proposed EPP Policy for the County, District Staff have been working to gain support for the Policy among various County departments before submitting it to the Administration and Board of County Commissioners. In addition, District Staff and the County Purchasing Office are in the process of developing resources for access by County departments looking to do EPP purchasing. These resources are expected to be completed by late February with training sessions to be held in early April. Staff will bring the EPP Policy before the Board of Commissioners in mid-March.
VI. Tentative Future Agenda Items
VII. Policy Committee Members' Comments
VIII. Public Comments
IX. Upcoming District Meetings
The date and time of the next regularly scheduled Policy Committee meeting will be Thursday, March 14, 2002, at 2:00 pm at the Hamilton County Department of Environmental Services, 250 William Howard Taft Road, Cincinnati, Ohio 45219.
X. Adjournment (Target Time: 3:30 p.m.)